# MSCI exclusions raise questions over how Bitcoin treasury companies are classified

By Riza Dagoc

Canonical URL: https://www.tokenpost.com/news/investing/58690
Published: 2026-11-16T18:20:26.000Z
Updated: 2026-11-16T18:20:26.000Z
Section: Investing

> George McHale questioned whether MSCI’s exclusion rules reliably distinguish operating companies from passive investment vehicles, while pointing to continued institutional Bitcoin adoption.

The criteria used to exclude Bitcoin treasury companies from global equity indexes need to be tested for whether they reliably distinguish operating businesses from passive investment vehicles. The central issue is the clarity and verifiability of the rules, rather than whether they discriminate against Bitcoin, according to George McHale.

In a Bitcoin Magazine interview on November 16, McHale, managing director at Bitcoin for corporations, challenged MSCI’s new non-operating company framework. He argued that an index provider’s role is to measure the market and questioned whether the framework instead determines which businesses count as part of it.

McHale said MSCI had confirmed that Strategy and Metaplanet would be removed from its global indexes. Bitcoin for corporations, which counts both companies as members, filed a formal complaint seeking withdrawal of the framework. He said the group had previously gathered 1,500 signatures and met with MSCI to challenge an earlier proposal, which did not proceed before a new screening framework emerged.

According to McHale, the screen first checks whether operating assets account for at least 50% of a company’s assets. Companies that fail that test face five financial ratios. He said vague language defining a non-operating company makes it difficult for businesses to establish whether they meet the requirements.

McHale said the exclusions also affected businesses without Bitcoin holdings, including London-based Yellow Cake, which holds physical uranium. Six companies were being removed and another 19 placed on a watch list, he said. He added that it remained difficult to determine whether SmarterWeb’s addition to the microcap index was related to the new screen.

He framed the complaint as a question of whether the rules can be independently checked. McHale said the boundary allowing a real estate trust to remain while excluding a uranium holder had not been published, and argued that MSCI needed to demonstrate that its framework consistently distinguishes operating companies from passive investment vehicles.

Separately, McHale said institutional Bitcoin adoption was continuing despite weak prices. He cited recent disclosures from about 2,000 institutions holding Bitcoin ETFs, including Wells Fargo and Morgan Stanley. He described demand as shifting toward institutional allocations after years in which retail investors built the market, emphasizing actual investment activity over short-term sentiment.

McHale nevertheless cautioned that only a handful of companies were likely to succeed by replicating the Bitcoin accumulation model established by Strategy and other large treasury holders. He argued that investors’ preference for companies with substantial existing Bitcoin holdings could limit the prospects of later entrants following the same approach.


