US economy has ‘forgotten how to grow’ as consumer spending and hiring weaken, Snider says
Jeffrey Snider says wealthy consumers are masking gradual weakness in US spending and hiring, while persistent living costs could fuel repeated voter rejection of incumbents.

The US economy faces a prolonged erosion of consumer spending and employment rather than a sudden collapse, with wealthy households supporting headline figures while pressures build on ordinary consumers and small businesses.
In an interview on Mario Nawfal’s X account on November 16, Jeffrey Snider, founder of Eurodollar University, described the economy as having “forgot how to grow.” He argued that the absence of a crisis resembling 2009 does not establish economic health: insufficient growth in jobs and incomes can steadily worsen household conditions.
Snider said spending by wealthy and ultrawealthy consumers was keeping aggregate consumption afloat, while other households were responding to expensive fuel by cutting convenience-store purchases such as drinks and snacks. He described modest declines in convenience-store sales and McDonald’s traffic, alongside retailers’ complaints about difficult trading conditions.
Weakness in major purchases offered further evidence, he said. Snider cited Whirlpool’s first annual loss in 39 years as a sign of consumers’ reluctance to buy expensive goods. He also pointed to National Association of Realtors figures showing existing-home sales at their lowest in 16 years, reaching back to 2010. He interpreted housing weakness as reflecting uncertainty about future income and its durability, alongside interest-rate pressures.
Snider linked the hiring slowdown to a gap between revenue and sales volumes. He argued that the pandemic, lockdowns and the policy response created economic imbalances, with businesses facing price pressures and disappointing volume growth after a temporary surge in 2021 and 2022. Higher prices lifted revenue without generating enough additional work to justify more employees, he said.
Employment growth can remain positive while falling short of what the economy needs, Snider said, leaving households progressively further behind. He described businesses as stopping recruitment and gradually reducing staffing rather than conducting the concentrated layoffs associated with a conventional recession. Companies that hired excessively in 2021 and 2022 had also been shrinking their payrolls, he said.
Tax cuts or greater government spending would struggle to resolve those distortions, Snider argued. Restoring economic balance could take years, and further intervention could make conditions worse, in his assessment. He also characterized the war as a final trigger for frustration among households already facing weak hiring and incomes that failed to keep pace with prices.
Persistent affordability pressures could sustain repeated changes in governing parties, Snider said. He called this an “eviction cycle,” driven by dissatisfaction with incumbents’ economic performance rather than durable support for their opponents. If underlying conditions fail to improve after changes in government, he warned, repeated disappointment could push some voters toward more extreme political positions.