Mbappé Episode Spurs Proposal for Coordinated Response to China
Victor Cha and Andy Lim propose a collective economic deterrence pledge after China-linked backlash against the soccer star. Their tally records 605 coercion cases since the 1990s.

Kylian Mbappé’s apology after a joke about a meme depicting him as Mao Zedong drew commercial and broadcast reactions in China, prompting two researchers to propose a coordinated government response to economic pressure.
A Chinese football forum picked up the meme in late October. Within a day of it circulating, three Chinese sponsors had dropped Mbappé. His name and image were also removed from advertising and store materials in China for Dior, Hublot, On and Adidas. China’s state broadcaster took Spanish league matches off its schedule, and Mbappé’s accounts on Weibo and Xiaohongshu were restricted.
Mbappé apologized for his “ill-judged” comment. La Liga President Javier Tebas apologized to Chinese fans, while Real Madrid apologized to the Chinese people for any discomfort caused by Mbappé’s words. China’s Foreign Ministry described the backlash as natural.
The episode echoes China’s response to a 2019 tweet about Hong Kong protests by Daryl Morey, then general manager of the Houston Rockets. All 11 official Chinese partners of the NBA suspended ties, and Chinese state media canceled broadcasts. The canceled broadcasts cost the league hundreds of millions of dollars.
Victor Cha, president of the Center for Strategic and International Studies’ Geopolitics and Foreign Policy Department and a Georgetown University professor, and Andy Lim, deputy director and fellow with the center’s Korea Chair, said their research recorded 605 cases of Chinese economic coercion since the 1990s. They counted 582 cases targeting companies and individuals over perceived slights involving the Chinese Communist Party’s legitimacy, territorial disputes, Tiananmen commemorations or arms sales. Almost none of the 605 cases involved trade.
Targets were overwhelmingly based in rich democracies. The G7 economies, Australia and South Korea accounted for 81% of the cases, Cha and Lim found.
The authors propose a collective economic deterrence pledge, under which governments would coordinate a response when companies or people from one country face pressure. They say it could begin with the G7, Australia and South Korea, with participation widened later.
They also urge the European Union to expand its Anti-Coercion Instrument, which allows the bloc to respond to foreign economic pressure against member states. The authors propose extending it to cover European companies and individuals as well.