Ninth Circuit Judges Question xAI on California AI Disclosure Law
At Wednesday’s hearing, Judge Johnnie Rawlinson challenged xAI’s First Amendment argument and asked whether California could seek information about what goes into AI systems.

The Ninth Circuit questioned xAI’s challenge to California’s AI training-data disclosure law at a Wednesday hearing, with judges pressing the company on its First Amendment claim and the state on the amount of information it can require.
xAI argues that the disclosure requirement compels speech and exposes proprietary details about how its models are trained. U.S. Circuit Judge Johnnie Rawlinson told xAI attorney James Xi that, in this challenge, the company must show the government’s request is unreasonable.
Rawlinson asked whether it was reasonable for the government to want people to know what information goes into AI systems. The judges also raised concern that California could compel disclosure of a “limitless” amount of information.
In March, a federal judge in Los Angeles rejected xAI’s request to pause the law, finding at that stage that the company had not shown it was likely to prevail on its constitutional claim.