2 min read
Add as a preferred source on Google

Ron Johnson’s Social Security Plan Carries a $190 Trillion Cost

The proposal would use Treasury general funds to maintain full benefits after trust fund reserves run out. Its estimated cost is spread over 75 years in inflation-adjusted dollars.

The Capitol rises behind a government building in morning light / TokenPost.ai
The Capitol rises behind a government building in morning light / TokenPost.ai

Sen. Ron Johnson, chairman of the Senate Budget Committee, proposed Nov. 18 using Treasury general funds to maintain full Social Security benefits after the retirement trust fund runs out, a plan estimated to add $190 trillion to the national debt over 75 years in inflation-adjusted dollars.

The projected cost equals 165% of gross domestic product. The proposal would let the Treasury secretary transfer money from the government’s general fund into the trust fund once its reserves are depleted.

The retirement trust fund is less than six years from running out. Under current law, benefits would then fall by about 22%. Roughly 70 million people receive Social Security benefits, and the avoided reduction would otherwise average about $500 a month per beneficiary.

The Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget calls the proposal the “Stop Scaring Seniors Act.” The group’s president, Maya MacGuineas, called it “a cynical pander that ducks all the real decisions we need to confront.” She warned that passing the bill could unsettle bond markets and said the borrowing could spark a crisis.

Johnson argues Americans have been misled about Social Security’s funding. A Senate Budget Committee report he released the same day projects a shortfall of about $511 billion by 2032. Johnson’s position is that workers’ contributions have gone to current beneficiaries or other government programs, leaving future benefits to be financed by future workers and borrowing.

MacGuineas called Johnson’s view that Congress should address the federal deficit as a whole reasonable. She criticized the proposal for failing to fix Social Security while increasing debt and suggested lawmakers consider a bipartisan commission.

Payroll taxes have funded Social Security benefits since the program began in the 1930s. The law limits payments to the amount held in the trust fund; Johnson’s plan would remove that limit and shift the funding gap to the Treasury.

The current $41.1 trillion debt limit is expected to begin binding in January, with borrowing room projected to run out around September 2027.

Riza Dagoc

Riza Dagoc reports on regulation, investing and the digital-asset business for TokenPost. Send corrections or tips to info@tokenpost.com.

Loading…