Column Asks Newsom Whether Reparations Would Extend to Other Groups
Jeff Davidson's Nov. 19 column sets $14 trillion in proposed reparations against nearly $22 trillion he says the U.S. has spent on affirmative action and wealth redistribution programs since the 1960s.
Jeff Davidson argued in a column published Thursday that many groups were mistreated in U.S. history, and he asked California Gov. Gavin Newsom whether their descendants would also be owed reparations.
Davidson wrote that the country cannot compensate every group that suffered unfair treatment. He called the push to redress all of history "pure folly."
What the column argues
Davidson asks whether descendants of European Jewish, Irish, Italian, Greek and eastern European immigrants would be owed payments. He also raises Chinese workers on the Pacific coast in the 1890s, women who were denied the right to vote until 1920, and the descendants of Union soldiers killed or wounded in the Civil War.
On the Central Pacific Railroad, Davidson says the company employed more than 12,000 Chinese workers in the 1800s and that they made up 90% of its workforce. He writes that those workers were underpaid, suffered high rates of injury, illness and death, and could not aspire to U.S. citizenship.
Davidson also offers two figures of his own. He says reparations proposed by some would total $14 trillion, and that the United States has spent nearly $22 trillion on affirmative action and wealth redistribution programs since the 1960s. From those numbers he concludes that the government has already paid more than the proposed reparations total.